Americans pour roughly as much coffee as they did in 2003, yet the calories riding along in those cups have climbed nearly 40%. After tracing 15 years of federal diet surveys covering 30,000 adults, a Tufts University team found the biggest culprit in the creamer jug, not the sugar bowl, as ScienceDaily’s summary explains.
Milk and sugar once led the additions. By the end of the study window, the whitener had passed them.
An average coffee drinker’s daily cups went from 43 to 60 calories between 2003 and 2018, with non-dairy creamer supplying the largest share of the extras by the end.
Coffee Drinking Stayed Flat While Its Calories Climbed

The figures come from eight consecutive rounds of the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, in which adults aged 20 and over reported what they ate and drank. Across those 15 years, daily coffee intake barely moved from about 13 ounces, while the calories taken in through it rose from 43 to 60 a day, according to Daily Coffee News’ coverage. The paper went online October 19 in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics.
Yongyi Pan, a Ph.D. candidate at the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy, led the work. Fang Fang Zhang, a nutrition professor at the school, served as senior author.
By 2018 The Whitener Outscored Sugar And Milk
Ranked by the calories each addition contributed per day in 2018, as Newsweek’s report gives them:
- Non-dairy creamer: 18.5 calories, up from 7.71 in 2003.
- Sugar and syrups: 16 calories.
- Dairy milk: 11 calories.
In other words, the creamer’s contribution more than doubled over the period, while the older additions held near their usual levels. Pan said the product “has increased in popularity in recent years as consumers seek plant-based or dairy alternatives,” in HealthDay’s report on MedicineNet.
Milk Still Wins By Weight
Measured in grams poured, dairy milk remained the most common addition, followed by the creamer and then sugar, as mindbodygreen’s write-up points out. The creamer took the calorie crown on less volume.
What Fills The Jug Went Unmeasured
Creamers vary widely between brands, from coconut-oil powders to sweetened oat blends, so the analysis couldn’t establish which ingredients drove the rise. Zhang noted in the Tufts release that cream and sugar in coffee can push up intake of added sugar and saturated fat, the two things dietary guidelines keep asking Americans to cut.
Plainer Cups Keep The Better Record In Other Studies
Daily Coffee News points to a 2026 study of more than 167,000 adults that linked unsweetened coffee, though not sweetened coffee, to lower cardiovascular disease risk. A 2025 Tufts analysis of over 46,000 adults tied black coffee, or coffee with little added sugar or saturated fat, to a lower risk of death. Retail data meanwhile show the U.S. creamer market growing on.
Set against those findings, a shift from sugar to creamer reads less like an upgrade than a sideways move.
Seventeen Extra Calories Sounds Small, So Judge It Over A Year
One cup proves little on its own, though a habit measured daily compounds across a year. The survey data also stop in 2018, so the paper cannot say how far the shift has carried since. Funding details weren’t given in the coverage reviewed.
Provided the morning cup stays, the cheapest fix is a look at the label: calories per serving on a creamer bottle assume a far smaller pour than most hands make. Measured milk came out lightest of the three main additions in this study. Plain black remains the version the long-term research keeps favoring, as our earlier piece on coffee and lower liver disease and cancer risk explains. For more on what processed additions do inside the body, see our report on ultra-processed meals and insulin response.

