Older Americans who ate the most ultra-processed food developed colorectal cancer at roughly the rate seen in those who ate the least, according to a study of 461,682 adults published October 15 in PLOS Medicine. The kind of processed food mattered far more than the total, as ScienceDaily’s summary of the paper explains.

Packaged whole-grain bread, cereal and dairy went with a lower rate of the disease. Processed meat went with a higher one.

Cutting ultra-processed food as a whole category is unlikely to lower colorectal cancer risk by itself, though cutting processed meat and eating more whole grains, fiber and dairy still lines up with the evidence.

Researchers Followed Over 460,000 Older Adults For Nearly Two Decades

The data came from the NIH-AARP Diet and Health Study. Its volunteers, aged 50 to 71, filled out food questionnaires in 1995 and 1996 and were then followed until 2018. Erikka Loftfield of the U.S. National Cancer Institute was the senior author, with Leila Abar as first author.

According to epocrates’ journal synopsis, the numbers break down like this:

  • Adults followed: 461,682, all cancer-free at the start.
  • Median follow-up: 18.8 years.
  • Cancers diagnosed: 10,075 colorectal adenocarcinomas.
  • Where they formed: 4,787 in the upper colon, 2,633 in the lower colon and 2,389 in the rectum.
  • Share of diet: ultra-processed food made up about 43% of what volunteers ate each day, on average.

The Heaviest Eaters Showed No Higher Rate Of The Disease

People in the top fifth for ultra-processed intake had a 3% lower risk than those in the bottom fifth, a difference small enough to be chance. Splitting the cancers by upper colon, lower colon and rectum still showed no clear link, as StudyFinds’ report notes. The comparison was adjusted for age, sex, race, education, smoking, alcohol, exercise, family history and self-rated health.

“In this large population of older US adults, we did not observe an association between total ultra-processed food intake and colorectal cancer incidence,” Loftfield said.

What You Eat From The Packet Matters More Than The Packet

Foods Linked To A Lower Rate

Whole grains, fiber, dairy and calcium were linked to fewer cancers, even when they came from ultra-processed sources such as packaged bread, breakfast cereal and yogurt. “Our results support a role for whole grain, fiber, dairy and calcium intake in (colorectal cancer) prevention that was not diminished by food processing level,” the scientists wrote, in PhillyVoice’s coverage.

Foods Linked To A Higher Rate

Processed meat from ultra-processed sources, such as hot dogs and reconstituted meat, went with more cancers, as long-standing advice on processed meat would lead you to expect.

Swapping 10% of the weight of ultra-processed food for minimally processed food, such as fresh produce, was associated with a 2% lower colorectal cancer rate.

Older, Mostly White Volunteers Limit What The Study Can Say

Eating habits were measured only once, at the start, so later changes in diet went unrecorded. Products on supermarket shelves have also changed a good deal since the mid-1990s. According to a release quoted by Money Talks News, the researchers caution against applying the findings to younger, more diverse groups, because the cohort was mainly older white Americans.

Younger adults are where the worry now lies. Colorectal cancer has become the leading cause of cancer death among Americans under 50, according to the American Cancer Society. This study cannot say much about why.

Keep Your Screening Up And Look At The Label, Not Just The Word “Processed”

Unless your doctor has advised otherwise, keep up with colorectal screening. In the U.S. it is recommended from age 45 for people at average risk. When shopping, a whole-grain loaf in a bag ought not to be judged like a pack of hot dogs.

Ultra-processed food may still matter for other reasons. Our earlier piece on how ultra-processed meals change insulin response covers one of them. Our report on a high-fiber diet compared with metformin looks at what fiber can do for blood sugar.

Leave a comment